Is it time to get rid of secondary schools?

One of the really interesting things that’s coming out of research I’m doing at the moment is just how increasingly irrelevant secondary schools really to the lives of young people. There’s loads of great stuff going on in Primary schools. Really innovative, pedagogically-sound stuff. There’s also awesome things happening in Further and Higher Education.

I don’t see it in Secondary schools. Pockets here and there perhaps, but not to the same extent. And, more to the point, nor do the researchers and innovators to whom I’ve been speaking.

So what’s the problem? What’s holding back innovation in secondary schools? Well…

  • Teachers blame senior leaders
  • Senior leaders blame the curriculum
  • The curriculum was, up until recently, the responsibility of the QCDA
  • The QCDA blames the examination boards
  • The examination boards blame the government
  • The government blames lack of innovation in schools.

Now that the QCDA has been given its notice, this is a massive opportunity for secondary schools. People talk about the ‘crisis in higher education’. That’s just a funding crisis. The real crisis is 11-16 year olds voting with their feet.

What can we do about it? Take a stand, for a start.

So I’m not really proposing that we just let anyone over the age of 11 wander the streets. Of course not. But I do think that the organizations that form the secondary ecosystem have a whole lot of work to do to win hearts and minds.



Comments policy
  • http://twitter.com/davestacey Dave Stacey

    Great post and follow up comments. I’m completely with Simon.

    I’m becomingly increasingly convinced that the thing we need to get rid of is the exam system. They were originally intended as a measure of achievement, back in the days when the purpose of education was to sort the ‘wheat’ from the ‘chaff’. Now they’re simply an end in themselves.

    If we’re re-imaging the secondary school experience, I suspect it will contain much more ‘real world’ experience. When I apply for a job these day, my GCSEs don’t count. In fact, neither do my A Levels or (I suspect in many cases) my degree. What does count is my experience as a teacher and my effectiveness at communicating that to a potential employer. This is backed up a reference from someone who can hopefully speak for my skills, and a portfolio of relevant examples should I choose. Why can’t we just roll that system back into our new schools.

    I suspect most businesses will be perfectly happy with this (many really aren’t that fussed about the paper qualifications anyway), the only people who may have an issue are those further up the academic ladder, and those people who haven’t realised that the world has changed, and so has the purpose of education.

    • http://dougbelshaw.com Doug Belshaw

      In a recent blog post Seth Godin talks about how insane it is in today’s
      world that we go with the shiny suit and the firm handshake at interview
      rather than the person with a history of ‘shipping’ (i.e. achieving relevant
      stuff). James Paul Gee talks about how once we embed game-based learning
      theory, we’ll have ‘levelling-up’ instead of exams.

      Can’t wait!